Proof Transformations from Search-oriented into Interaction-oriented Tableau Calculi
نویسندگان
چکیده
Logic calculi, and Gentzen-type calculi in particular, can be categorised into two types: search-oriented and interaction-oriented calculi. Both these types have certain inherent characteristics stemming from the purpose for which they are designed. In this paper, we give a general characterisation of the two types and present two calculi that are typical representatives of their respective class. We introduce a method for transforming proofs in the search-oriented calculus into proofs in the interactionoriented calculus, and we demonstrate that the di culties arising with devising such a transformation do not pertain to the speci c calculi we have chosen as examples but are general. We also give examples for the application of our transformation procedure.
منابع مشابه
A Non-clausal Connection Calculus
A non-clausal connection calculus for classical first-order logic is presented that does not require the translation of input formulae into any clausal form. The definition of clauses is generalized, which may now also contain (sub-) matrices. Copying of appropriate (sub-)clauses in a dynamic way, i.e. during the actual proof search, is realized by a generalized extension rule. Thus, the calcul...
متن کاملProof Confluent Tableau Calculi
A tableau calculus is proof confluent if every partial tableau proof for an unsatisfiable formula can be extended to a closed tableau. A rule application may be redundant but it can never prevent the construction of a proof; there are no “dead ends” in the proof search. Proof confluence is a prerequisite of (a) backtrackingfree proof search and (b) the generation of counter examples to non-theo...
متن کاملProgram Synthesis and Transformations in an Object-oriented Environment Program Synthesis and Transformations in an Object-oriented Environment
An object-oriented language with automatic synthesis of methods (programs) and transformations of OO descriptions using a logical metalanguage (Horn-clause logic) are considered. Automatic synthesis of methods (Proof-As-Program approach) is based on in-tuitionistic propositional calculus. The metalanguage expresses general knowledge related to classes and objects and it is used for describing t...
متن کاملA Cut-free Tableau Calculus for the Logic of Common Knowledge
In this paper we focus on the development of a cut-free finitary tableau calculus with histories for n-agent modal logics with common knowledge (LCK). Thus, we get a proof system where proof-search becomes feasible and we lay the basis for developing a uniform framework for the treatment of the family of logics of common knowledge. Unlike proof calculi based on temporal logics, our calculus giv...
متن کاملFull First-Order Free Variable Sequents and Tableaux in Implicit Induction
We show how to integrate implicit inductive theorem proving into free variable sequent and tableau calculi and compare the appropri-ateness of tableau calculi for this integration with that of sequent calculi. When rst-order validity is introduced to students it comes with some complete calculus. If this calculus happens to be an analytic calculus augmented with a Cut rule like a sequent or tab...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- J. UCS
دوره 5 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 1999